Business Week March 2005
First came pacemakers. Now exotic implants are bringing new hope to victims of epilepsy, paralysis, depression, and other diseases
The potential is great. Unlike most drugs, these implants produce few side effects. The devices also are aimed at prevalent diseases that can't always be treated with drugs. As a result, medical-products executives and their surgeon partners predict that such implants could one day become as common as cardiac devices, which are currently helping 2 million Americans.
Little wonder, then, that some of the biggest names in health care are in a scramble to get into the market. Most recently, in December, Johnson & Johnson (JNJ ) bought implant-maker Guidant Corp. (GDT ) for $23.9 billion. "Any organ that a nerve can influence -- and that's every organ in the body -- can be affected using this technology," says Dr. Ali R. Rezai, who is director of functional neurosurgery at the
The use of implantable mini-generators is more widespread than you probably think. Already, 190,000 patients are wearing electrodes in their heads to control Parkinson's disease tremors or spinal-cord stimulators to relieve pain or prevent urinary incontinence. Some 30,000 have wires threaded to the vagus nerve in the neck to treat epilepsy, while 60,000 have microtransmitters in the inner ear enabling them to hear. These numbers are likely to grow -- and quickly. One of the most promising devices is a $15,000 neurostimulator for chronic depression from Cyberonics Inc. (CYBX ), which the Food & Drug Administration conditionally approved on Feb. 2.
Candy Bradshaw can testify to the power of neurostimulation. She had a gastric pacemaker implanted in her abdomen in 1999 at
As neurostimulators get even smaller and their microchips more powerful, researchers foresee new uses for these implants. Advanced Bionics Corp., a startup that Boston Scientific Corp (BSX ). acquired in 2004, is testing a rechargeable device so tiny that it can be injected almost anywhere in the body to treat pain or muscle dysfunction. Implants also could act as sensors, telling a miniature pump when to deliver a drug or customized protein to a precise location in the body. "The body is on fire with electricity," says Dr. Stephen N. Oesterle, chief medical officer at Medtronic Inc (MDT )., the No. 1 maker of implantable electrical devices. "If you start with that concept, then all you need is imagination."
The neuromodulation market is potentially enormous. There are up to 3 million Americans with chronic migraines and 4 million with depression who do not respond to drugs. The number of morbidly obese American adults is also estimated at 4 million. An additional 5 million Americans have been crippled to some degree by stroke, and the number grows by about 750,000 each year. Most of these people won't rush out and have surgery. But if only a fraction get an implant, executives at medical-device companies project that overall sales of noncardiac pulse generators should balloon from $1.6 billion today to $10 billion in 10 to 15 years, depending on how quickly the FDA approves new uses. "Ultimately," says Todd K. Whitehurst, vice-president for emerging indications at Advanced Bionics in
The returns for investors may also be substantial. Today, most neurostimulators don't make money because years of research and development and marketing outlays overwhelm what are, in the beginning, only trickling revenue streams. Still, Advanced Neuromodulation Systems Inc. (ANSI ), of
As sales grow, device makers will be able to spread their expenses over a wider base and become more efficient manufacturers. If the FDA approves their new treatments, says Jan D. Wald, a medical-device analyst at A.G. Edwards & Sons Inc. (AGE ) in
Over time, however, these devices may restore more than lives; they could save money, too. In a comprehensive review of spinal-cord stimulation, a doctor and an economist at
Neurostimulation has another selling point: Because the implants alter tissue only at their points of contact, side effects are generally negligible. Most say they can't sense the stimulation at all. Contrast that with the most common drug treatment, Dilantin, which can cause dizziness and nausea and can lead to liver damage. "Think of the device as a smart bomb“says Advanced Neuromodulation (ANSI ) CEO Christopher G. Chavez.
Medical-device executives and surgeons point out that today's implants are not generally intended to be a first-line treatment. Someone with heart trouble, for instance, would start off on a cholesterol-reducing drug and a stricter diet before getting outfitted with an implantable defibrillator. The same goes for neurostimulators, which are meant for patients with illnesses or disabilities for which there are no other treatments. People like Judith Walsh of
Last February, Walsh began electrical-stimulation therapy. In a clinical study sponsored by Northstar Neuroscience Inc., doctors at
Today, Walsh can make a peanut-butter and jelly sandwich and grip the steering wheel of her car with her left hand. More gratifying, she says, she can feed and dress her five-month-old granddaughter, Emma, things she couldn't do with her three older grandchildren when they were babies. "It's hard, as a grandmother, not to be able to hold the grandchildren -- and now I'm able to do that," she says. "It's the thrill of my life." Executives at Northstar, a
On Feb. 2, the FDA cleared Cyberonics' vagus-nerve stimulator for chronic depression, pending some clarification on the labelling of the device. Chairman and CEO Robert P. "Skip" Cummins says Cyberonics analyzed results from 240 people with long-term depression after two years of neurostimulation. All of the subjects had failed to respond to drugs. The analysis found that half the patients were markedly better, with 18% reporting they were no longer depressed. With the FDA's go-ahead, Cummins says, Cyberonics will begin pilot studies on Alzheimer's disease, headache, anxiety disorders, and bulimia. Medtronic also may be closing in on a number of new therapies. Its products are in clinical tests to pulse the thalamus to treat epilepsy; another region of the deep brain to treat migraines, depression, and obsessive-compulsive disorder; the hypoglossal nerve in the neck to treat sleep apnea; the sacral nerve to treat bowel disorders; and the stomach to treat obesity. Medtronic may have a deep-brain treatment for epilepsy in two or three years.
New treatments may become feasible as device sizes shrink and rechargeable batteries evolve. Advanced Bionics, for example, has developed a rechargeable implant that is about the size of an ink tube from a ballpoint pen cut to a one-inch length. Its first use, already permitted in
The leading cardiac-device makers are packing their newest implants with enough computing power to sense the environment around them and alter a patient's treatment as needed. A next step would be to link sensor-laden neurostimulators to miniature drug pumps. In this way, a patient could be dosed exactly when needed and at the precise site where the medication is most effective. Researchers say this could reduce dosages by a thousandfold and avert side effects. Such systems would also enable a patient to be treated with bioengineered drugs and proteins too large to be absorbed by swallowing a pill. The combined therapy seems most promising in the brain, where many disorders might be tackled with protein drugs complemented by electrical pulses.
As these new therapies move closer to reality, the medical-products companies are putting down their markers. Last June, Boston Scientific paid $740 million in cash to acquire Advanced Bionics. Boston Scientific also holds a 14% stake in Cyberonics. Then in December came J&J's megadeal with Guidant. Although Guidant does not have any neurostimulators in clinical trials, the